Sunday, September 18, 2016

Uri Notes For Modi



In recent meetings of the G20 and ASEAN, PM Narendra Modi has demanded sanctions against Pakistan and to declare it a “Terrorist state”. These and his actions and statements on Balochistan and POK were very welcome and a departure from past govts. It has also brought attention to Pak violations of human rights and killings in Balochistan and POK. The question now is: What will ModiSarkar do after the latest terror attack in Uri at an army camp? The camp is reportedly one where Jawans changing shifts or postings reside and is more of a make-shift camp. After the Pathankot attack in January 2016 this is what DM Manohar Parikkar had to say:

Let’s get some perspective. In November 2011 NATO forces attacked Pak troops at the Afghan border. This resulted in casualties and Pak responded by shutting down the supply routes for the US to Afghanistan. It was shut down for over six months till Hillary Clinton apologised sometime in 2012. Even a terrorist-state responds with some action to attacks on them, even if incidental. But a massive country like India with a million-plus in the army continues to merely mouth verbal condemnations after every terror attack on India and particularly on our troops in Kashmir. And this is going on for 25 years now.

In 25 years of terrorism that we have faced in Kashmir and other places in India, our GOI has not retaliated even once. We have never crossed the LOC ever. What is the message we have been consistently sending Pak? “Kill as many as you can but we will keep up our verbal condemnation and nothing else”. This emboldens more terrorism and more brazen attacks even on our Jawans. Here is what Modi tweeted about the UPA govt in August 2013:

What is it that you are prepared to do now? What is ModiSarkar going to do? There is no doubt that terror attacks across the board have gone down since May 2014 but wanton attacks on our Jawans as in Pathankot or Uri simply cannot go unpunished or without a price to pay for Pakistan. Here is another taunt from Modi to the UPA in his “Doob maro, Doob maro” speech on Pak terror attacks (Video 0.19 secs):

video
Let us understand how our Jawans died in the Uri camp. According to TV reports most of the deaths were not caused by their battling terrorists. Most of them were killed in their tents in fires caused by grenade attacks. 17 of them died for nothing. The deaths and injuries might go up. The attack came on a day when a one army unit was replacing another at the LOC. Someone is leaking such information. Who are these traitors? -And all that happens is people like Rajnath, Parrikar and others hold emergency meetings. This is not the language that Pakistan understands which Modi wants to speak to them. A surprise visit to Pak to attend the birthday party of Nawaz Sharif laden with gifts is not the message to a terrorist-state.

There is something more alarming and disgusting as well. The ministers and sidekicks of ModiSarkar are unable to stop hobnobbing with terror-sympathisers like NDTV or the Kashmiri-instigator Barkha Dutt. Even Sajjad Lone was blunt enough to tell the woman her reports cause unrest. Curbing “Terror support services” within India does not take dealing with Pak or terror groups. What is the message you send when parade with people like these?

The blurbs are a sarcastic comment on the dumbness of the Home Minister who blabbers his “Kadi Ninda” after every terror attack. It has already become a comic joke. What every govt at the Centre has demonstrated since the 1990s is that none has the guts to combat terrorism or take punitive measures for deaths caused. ModiSarkar cannot even stop bogus reporting from Kashmir or conflict-zones by Barkha Dutt or other reporters who make hay while the terrorists kill or riots are inflamed. It would be ignorance if the GOI still does not realise that terrorists don’t merely want to kill – they want the media to provide them publicity and propaganda:

Priming! That’s right. Certain elements in MSM “prime” the publicity and propaganda for terrorists through their TV channels or print or even social media. And our Home Minister puts out some of the worst delusional messages, like this one after the Pathankot terror-attack:

Seriously, Pakistan has been exposed many times in the last 70 years and that doesn’t shock anyone. It is the GOI that is being badly exposed as pussy-footed for 25 years when it comes to terrorism. Through his global reach and speeches Modi has definitely turned Pakistan into an international pariah. What exactly does India stand to gain with this terrorist state? He wants world powers to pass sanctions against Pak. He wants to Pak to be termed a terrorist-state. Rajnath Singh grandly states after the Uri attack that Pak is a terrorist state:

And this guy, Ram Madhav, who is constantly chattering with NDTV and Barkha Dutt is another big blabber-mouth of the BJP. The PM promises the terrorists will be punished? How? And what exactly was the “Strategic Restraint” policy? Where do these concocted silly terms come from? The terrorists or fidayeens don’t care a damn if our Jawans die. Does our own GOI care anymore? This stupid loud-mouthed blabbering is the biggest insult heaped on the Jawans killed or the innocents that die:

Both Modi and Rajnath want Pak to be declared a terrorist-state. Who should do that? Some third country? Why is it that India is not willing to take the first step instead of waiting for everyone else to fight for her? Nobody is going to fight for India. Foreign media like AP or BBC still call these terrorists “Rebels” as if they are locals who are revolting against some political issue. Who is ModiSarkar waiting for? The new president of the US? Nobody is going to do it for you. I believe time has come that we put Pak in a hole – first through non-military actions:

# Declare Pakistan a terrorist-state officially and cut off all bilateral ties with a resolution in the parliament. Withdraw the MFN status and cut off all ties.
# Expel the Pak envoy from Delhi and recall our envoy from Pak. Shut down our missions and ask all Indian citizens to return home.
# The Pak envoy is an extreme India-hater who courts love with the separatists who want to break India.
# Ask all Pak citizens to return back. Nobody knows how many are still living illegally in India. Ban all travel by Indians to Pak.
# Ban appearance of all Pak panellists in any Indian media. All they do is abuse India and claim all terror attacks are self-inflicted by India to bad-mouth Pak.
# Make any sympathy for terrorists of any form severely punishable by law.
# Ban all cultural ties and ban all references to Pak by hate-mongers in Bollywood. Make no mistake, Pak-sympathisers even in Bollywood don’t do it accidentally.
# No more visits to Pak by any minister or PM. Not even for SAARC or any multi-lateral summits.
# Get rid of Pakistan from SAARC. Nobody needs this sewer of a country which brings no value to any of the SAARC members. Even Bangladesh blames it for terror-attacks.

What exactly do we want or gain from Pakistan? Nothing! When will we start putting our own interests above this stupid country? We have nothing to gain – not even business of any size is meaningful to us. Enough of “Kadi Ninda” or “Strongly Condemn”. Any military action across the LOC can wait another day. Pakistan does not want peace with India. Only the most delusional Indians think it does. It has declared a 1000-year holy jihad against India. There’s no need for more Jawans or innocent people to die. After Uri if the GOI still goes soft – I’m sure India will be seen as a soft, cowardly country not by others but by Indians themselves
 

73 comments :

  1. As always to the point.if GOI doesn't show balls now, we as a nation will be seen as sissys and get more taunts from World

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Modis 56 inch chest has reduced to 28 it seems

      Delete
  2. If nothing is done by Modi Sarkar, he would go down in History as the most coward leader of India ever..

    Modi.. be brave enough.. we are with you.. don't be a coward..

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mr. Vinayak - "most coward" because of his own standards otherwise earlier govt. were far worse.

      Delete
    2. Declare PAK as a country commenced war and treat the incidence to punish and protect all national interest

      Delete
  3. To be fair, it's a little premature to declare that Modi has done nothing about Uri. This is the first time that the PM, and key ministers tweeted "purpetrators will be punished" and not "brought to justice." I'm sure South Block is working on something. Should give them a little time.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't have much confidence on Modi. He is kavi Vajpayee 2.

      Delete
    2. But the first response should be SEEN to be inimical to ANYONE perpetrating violence against the state. Including those within the nation who coo with the hawks and mouth unacceptable excuses for these attacks. So the first off pronouncements should show intent. Action may take time but the signals...?

      Delete
  4. Really hope that Modi shows us some displayable action against pak this time. We are sick of verbal condemnation, dossier games and begging pak to act...

    ReplyDelete
  5. Till 2014 we all thought we are a soft cowardly country and hoped things would change once NaMo became PM. But what a disappointment he has turned out to be in dealing with terrorism. He has shown he is no different from UPA govt in dealing with Pak. Today is the defining moment in his and his party's political life, if he sits twiddling thumbs even now he and his party is finished and the first sign of it will be shown in the upcoming elections. 2019 BJP will be back to double digits, doesn't matter who leads the CON party.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There is no cow. He has been berating gau rakshaks and promoting beef exports.

      Delete
  6. Dear Medaicrooks, good blog, but the points you have mentioned are very much a policy decision of the national politics, this might be in NaMo mind, but putting it in your blog makes it open and may reduce the end effect, I am sure you have good contacts with PM better write directly to him so that you can contribute to his action, my request is please advise and suggest directly, your points are worth discussion in MOE, HMO and PMO office, please think and comment @1967Babu.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mr. Babu, I'm responding unsolicitedly. Ravinar's these blogs seemingly were read by Mr. Modi before elections. He or we are not sure if they are being read and felt. Otherwise (if Modiji & PMO read through with meaning) Barkha Dutt would not be seem accompanying Rajnath Singh in the last visit. If open blogs reduce the effect of policy then be it. Pak open murders and attacks need to be penned in some way and our leadership must be shown the way how public feels.

      Delete
    2. Modi is a fraud and chela of Jaitley. Stop expecting anything from him except more of chrislamic appeasement - Teresa mata ki jai and increase of madarsas funding.

      Delete
  7. All actions simply put as a ready recokner to 56" Narendra Modi. If No balls to act only God can save india

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hope Modiji and BJP know the pulse of the people. Nationalists are not like CONGI slaves. They vote for principles. If this pussyfooting continue 2019 would be a disaster for BJP. First of all Modiji and BJP should ask their ministers and leaders to shun anti-national media and media persons.Second should take stringent action against Pak, starting with declaring it as a Terrorist state and cancellation of all kinds of relationship with it. Else we will have no alternative other than to keep stay put in our houses on polling day. Development is not an alternative to hard decisions in National interest.

    We have our prayers and whole hearted support for Mediacrooks on his crusade against real Media crooks and anti-nationals.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Absolutely sensible & do-able suggestions in the end.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Today all nations facing one or the other threat which can if not handled well taking to next gen war.
    U can see today enemy countries becoming friends & the other way also.
    So a calculated offensive strike

    ReplyDelete
  11. Enough is enough. Eventually politicians all seem to be cut out from the same fabric. Time for action not comments and dosiers.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Don't care about your international image like Nehru did, act like Golda Meir and Israel

    ReplyDelete
  13. When BJP itself is trying to buy the media like congress.what can one do but wait for idiots like Rammadhav. and it buys media support by ignoring BanK defaults by media groups in the South of chennai city...

    ReplyDelete
  14. #Pertinent ideas and you hit the #BullsEye.
    Nothing else to do, than to stop #Bilateral #Relations.

    Recall our #Diplomats and give #Marching orders to #Hurriyat supporting Paki High Commissioner.
    #Revoke #MFN status to #Pakistan.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Hope, everybody concerned reads yr blog and do the needful

    ReplyDelete
  16. What likes Shekhar Gupta must be suggesting you have done most succiently. I full agree with you.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Aptly written.We have had soft defence policy from last 30 years just to appease Pakistan and the Muslim votes.We always knew Congress hates India and it's people.But BJP being in majority and still pussy footing makes me angry.Modi is becoming Atal part 2, just like the Kandahar failures where we refueled the plane and our 15 lac army was kept waiting.Shame on BJP.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Aptly written.We have had soft defence policy from last 30 years just to appease Pakistan and the Muslim votes.We always knew Congress hates India and it's people.But BJP being in majority and still pussy footing makes me angry.Modi is becoming Atal part 2, just like the Kandahar failures where we refueled the plane and our 15 lac army was kept waiting.Shame on BJP.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Recall our envoy to Pak
    Scrap Indus Water Treaty!

    Modi is losing the plot quickly and he is afraid of calls from the White House.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Modi knows Only Marketing...Dont expect Any thing from Him...

    ReplyDelete
  21. Modi knows Only Marketing...Dont expect Any thing from Him...

    ReplyDelete
  22. So called hawks in BJP, pull your socks up and bear down on the one person Mr Modi, to act tough towards Pakistan and its stooges. we all had put our faith that he will lead us with a iron hand

    ReplyDelete
  23. GOI acknowledged your "Terror support service " theory and started working on it. Now What r you up to ?? unable to understand . .. but sth very deterrent to Pak! common people wont understand this.

    "Mastering the Art of getting things done ..through twitter"

    ReplyDelete
  24. Awesome article. I agree to most of the points but it seems premature as so many things are being done by modi govt on all fronts, esp in tackling Pak as well as J&K
    In this chess India is damaging Pak internally, which is evident by Pak's reaction.
    Defence is all about secrecy hence we wont exactly know what is happening but we can connect the dots.

    ReplyDelete
  25. I full agree that the blabbering from Modi Sarkar is equivalent to that of previous govts.
    If our PM is serious about India being a Super Power then his and his ministers' words should be supported by legitimate action.

    How the hell Pakistan is MFN till date?
    Why don't we instead declare Pakistan Enemy State?

    The above are 2 things which I think is something which the GoI has not done makes its office bearers, read PM and ministers, look like fools who only blabber hard words and do nothing.

    I would want a special session of parliament be called and declare Pakistan a Terrorist State and Enemy State for India.

    How can our govt ask for UN to call Pakistan a Terrorist State but their own govt GoI is considering Pakistan as MFN.

    ReplyDelete
  26. We have seen almost 25 years of terrorism emanating & supported by Pakis. During these years, India was led by PMs ranging from Indira, Rajiv, VPSingh, PVNR, Chandrasekhar,DeveGowda, Gujral, Vajpayee, Manmohan Singh & now Modi. But none after Rajiv had a massive mandate like Modi has. This coupled with Modi's reputation, only hope for taking strictest of actions against Pakis is Modi in his current tenure.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Dr. Swamy once said, inaction against Pakistan is linked to corruption as ISI controls the hawala route and knows who are the politicians and so can easily blackmail them. That's making the most sense and explains the inaction. its not just cowardice or indecision, its blackmail. Hope I'm wrong.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes. That is the only plausible reason.

      Delete
  28. Modi is just a loud mouth. His impromptu impulsive to Lahore was extremely silly and childish. This is not the way a PM should behave. Is he upto the job? All he does is make speeches with Jaitley as defacto PM.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Spot on Ravinar!!. HMO n PM...grow a spine. U hv absolute majority n yet u go for consensus??!! Ppl voted u for change albeit not change into khangress style rats.
    A snake is a snake is a snake..get it?? Some ppl r just born evil n no matter how goody goody u try to behave it will never change that person..just accept fact that the persons genetically born twisted n stop ur stupid misplaced emotions drama. HMO is in rhetorics bcos of his kadi NIND. Ppl r tired of ur rhetorics n empty blabber ...u lose nothing but we hv to bear the brunt of ur cowardice by living in fear n footing ur stupid bills theu our taxes.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We thought Modi was different. He is no different. All poll promises ditched after getting the chair. Humbug.

      Delete
  30. Sorry Ravinar..I like your posts..for their no nonsense approach..but this one is just Gibberish...like George Bush said: revenge is best served cold. I am confident Modi will respond and inflict damage to Pak and bring it to its knees...will happen!
    After all 9/11 response was not effected on 10/11

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Tareekh pe tareekh. Like bringing back black money and pursuing mega scams tees, we are waiting and waiting and waiting and waiting .......... Modi has lost the plot. He ditched past experiences and all poll promises and went on a wooing Pakistan mission. He thought he had the magic to straighten a dog's tail. His credibility is in a shambles.

      Delete
    2. I have been following this blog for quite some time now. There are outstanding posts which make you think hard, including this post. However I feel for this particular subject, outburst of impatience and quick fix measures will not help. We voted for the BJP not for overnight transformation. I'm sure our Hon PM has a short term as well as a long term plan for this problem. It takes time...several decades sometimes, perhaps we wont even be alive to see this transformation. Its interesting to see that people are now talking about performance of government and timelines. Someone like me who never followed politics / current affairs is now actively taking interest in these subjects...and I'm sure there are many more like me out there. I think of this as a positive transformation in itself. Our Hon. PM follows his own timetable, we can only speculate what his next move is going to be...

      Delete
  31. After all 9/11 was not answeted on 9/12

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. we hvnt even caught ppl responsible for 93 bombay blasts.wht are you exactly expecting??

      Delete
  32. HM is sounding more like shivraj patil. as long as our bureaucrats, diplomats, media, academicians etc remains paki sympathizer nothing will change. to retaliate we need to prepare, takes time. with babus in pay commission relegating armed forces to police force where will things go.
    http://www.asianage.com/mumbai/india-pakistani-wage-robowars-854
    this is what we have at institute level going on, and you expect a fight.
    we are lucky pakis are not nuking us.

    ReplyDelete
  33. The way Modi is going about doesn't inspire any confidence! Worse than him are the bunch of cabinet ministers constantly hobnobbing with Bark Ah Dottas of anti-india media and mouthing incomprehensible and detestable 'kadi nindas'!!

    ReplyDelete
  34. I got it all now, Modi & his men have been hand picked to fool Indians by UPA through their blue eyed boy Arun Jaitley, we have to look for a new savior for 2019 folks

    ReplyDelete
  35. मोदीजी की रणनीति व ध्येयधारणाओं पर अविश्वास करने का न तो यह कारण है न ही उचित समय ही है। धैर्य और आस्था बनाये रखने का परिणाम देशहित में ही होगा।
    मोदी मोदी हैं!

    ReplyDelete
  36. Narendra Modi should be very careful and not tale impulsive action. We are no longer same country when Indira Gandhi decided to participate in Bangladesh war. Entire country was behind her. Now the moment Modi decides to attack Pakistan, opposition parties and the leftist media start second guessing and attacking Indian government. As a rule attacking army sacrifices lives of more soldiers than defending army because the defending army soldiers can occupy strategically advantageous position to kill invading soldiers.

    ReplyDelete
  37. An astounding article and highly pragmatic and stern line of actions suggested but whether our Government do that? Dont thinkso! Even now while I type the comment, the news report is that Modi wants to have an all party meeting and consensus on the line of action to alienate Paksitan to be taken! I dont understand in which world does our PM live in. He expects the Congis,Leftists and other whiners of political parties to support. Already INC has started derogatory tweets. Its time Modiji understands the ground situation and the feeling of the Public. No other nation would have sat idle for more than 25years offering soldiers as Qurbani and just make staetements and hold high level meeting. The elevation of Modiji as PM and appointment of Doval as NSA were supposed to be road map for strong action against Pakistan. But Modiji seems to be too timid! Another point is that if strong action is taken i.e. on the lines brought out inthe article, the political clout of our PM will only rise and not fall down and especially in Punjab and UP. A general sense is that almost all in India want action against Pakistan. Modiji should ignore the shameless congress, commies and other stooges!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Modiji should stop consulting other parties. He has the mandate for action up to 2019; then where is the need to consult faltoo ke jokers, corrupt politicians of anti-indian parties?

      Delete
  38. Modi has a 56 inch chest but appears to be devoid of balls

    ReplyDelete
  39. Rajnath Singh is important only because of UP,with elections around.Nirmala Sitaraman is strong and immensely thorough by any standard.But she cannot bring popular votes to BJP in UP or anywhere else.My be V.K.Singh is the right person as HM.But looking at the naivity of UP electorate who throng to listen to Rahul Gandhi's stupid comments,there are very little options for Modi and so we have to suffer Rajnath Singh.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Rise up UP walas. Don't be Biharis by bringing wrong people to power. Otherwise you would suffer the same jungle raj like Bihar.

      Delete
  40. how about abrogating indus water treaty. A simple yet far reaching action that GOI can take.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. To start, force no fly zone over POK. Shoot down anything that fly in POK. hope we have the capability.

      Delete
    2. Blocking the water flow is a very powerful "non military" approach which can yield very good results. India is a sovereign country and we should show the middle finger to UN or anyone else who tries to intervene when we stop the Indus flow.

      Delete
  41. Spot on blog. This is as it is a possibility wether we speak of Balochistan or POK. Govt needs to scrap Indus water treaty and also stop exports and imports from Pakistan. Sending arms to dismember Pakistan would be a workable response.

    ReplyDelete
  42. Spot on blog. This is as it is a possibility wether we speak of Balochistan or POK. Govt needs to scrap Indus water treaty and also stop exports and imports from Pakistan. Sending arms to dismember Pakistan would be a workable response.

    ReplyDelete
  43. The best analytical piece with sense and patriotism. A no nonsense.. No excuses.. no shufflefeet responses.. No motormouth asinine comments from BJP AND GoI. A list of things we should and can do. And make it permanent for all times to come. Like laws.. Park resolutions. This is what it's all about.

    ReplyDelete
  44. The best analytical piece with sense and patriotism. A no nonsense.. No excuses.. no shufflefeet responses.. No motormouth asinine comments from BJP AND GoI. A list of things we should and can do. And make it permanent for all times to come. Like laws.. Park resolutions. This is what it's all about.

    ReplyDelete
  45. After the NYC and NJ bombing we all got alerts about the terrorist on our cell phones and within 40 hours with the help of the citizens he was caught. The Govt. PM and president should read this article and immediately take all the above actions before attacking. I don't know why the embassy was not asked to leave just after the attack. That will send a signal to the world and Pak.

    ReplyDelete
  46. While i agree that relations cant be normal anymore with Pak, it is suicidal to cut off all kinds of relation with Pak including recalling of our envoy. Just imagine the situation of say an indian airplane wanting to make an emergency landing somewhere in Pak. After landing the passengers may even become hostages in their hands.The same holds for pak as well.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Keep your hesitations and doubts to yourself man. On this analogy you should not fight a dacoit just because perhaps you may need his help some day!!!

      Delete
  47. While military response would have been a visible response which would have appealed to public,It would have put India on back foot in international community. As Pakistan is trying to highlight the Kashmir issue, military response would have favoured Pakistan in achieving its objective and would have neutralized the diplomatic effort made by India in isolating Pakistan as India would have been seen as a aggressor. Military response is not a long term solution. I would agree with Ravinar regarding most of the suggestions. Something seems to be happening on the SAARC front, but before we ask others to isolate Pakistan, India should take the first step by blocking all economic ties with Pakistan. Interpretation of visible response varies and need not necessarily be military response. Hope Modi government starts isolating Pakistan by taking tough measures on its part first before sending diplomats.

    ReplyDelete
  48. Right advice at the right time to the right man.RSS/BJP should turn this in to an opportunity to prove to Indian electorate that BJP is a party with a difference. There are few more non military options available to India [1] Abrogate article 370 and start settling ex.servicemen in Kashmir valley [2] Give asylum to Brahumdagh Bugti and other Baloch freedom fighters and declare [ giving two hoots to the world and UN] that India will work for the freedom of Balochistan [3] Dismiss PDP-BJP govt in J & K and impose president rule with some one like KPS Gill as the governor [4] Start arming Afghanistan and station our troops in Kabul all at the invitation of Afghan government.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Also form a regiment of Balochi men, arm them, train them militarily and infiltrate them into Balochistan through Arabian Sea for guerrilla Warfare against Porkistan like we did with 'Shanti Vahini'in Bangladesh.

      Delete
  49. India is a soft and cowardly country. Dont believe????.... watch Rajnath Singh its Home Minister.

    ReplyDelete

Comments are welcome and are not moderated so as to allow free speech. However, comments that are off topic, abusive, defamatory or slanderous may be deleted. Comments disclosing personal information of individuals/entities will be deleted.Comments appearing here do not imply endorsement by author of this blog.