Friday, October 19, 2012

Zee News - Media Mafia Sinks To A New Low



Blackmail, extortion is not new to the news media. This is one of the reasons I call the media “India’sBiggest Mafia”. Here’s a report from Sucheta Dalal (from 2003) that I quoted in a previous post:

Last week, the Mumbai police arrested Rishi Chopra of The Economic Times along with an accomplice (a former journalist with another business daily) in an alleged extortion attempt. The duo was trapped accepting a Rs 700,000 bribe which was the second installment of a Rs 2.5 million payoff to kill a report about the shenanigans of one Poonamchand Malu of Malu Financial Services. Worse, the pay-off itself had apparently been haggled down from an initial demand of Rs 10 million to Rs 2.5 million. Although corruption in the media is no longer news, the actual arrest of two scribes and the sums involved, marked a new low in this once honourable profession”.

We now have a new case where Congress MP Naveen Jindal’s company Jindal Steel & Power Ltd. (JSPL), in a reverse sting, has filed an FIR against officials of the Zee News group for blackmailing them to the tune of 100 crores for suppressing news related to their involvement in Coalgate. The FIR includes tapes of recorded conversations between JSPL officials and Zee representatives in at least three meetings. Currently, the blackmail is stated to be in the form of advertisements demanded by Zee. The tapes have been sent for forensic examination according to the latest reports (The Hindu – October 15).

This is what The Hindu states: According to the FIR, the meetings between JSPL officials and Zee representatives took place on September 13, 17 and 19 at a South Delhi hotel. On the first day, the FIR states, three JSPL officials met one of the journalists during which Rs. 20 crore was demanded in the shape of advertisements and in the second meeting the demand was scaled up.

None of this is surprising. I have been a witness to rival groups of publications blackmailing companies and seeking advertisements for many years. One can also safely assume that is a common practice in media. Some media outlets may be brazen and some maybe subtle but gentle arm twisting is a standard wide-spread practice. In this case, the sum being demanded or negotiated was huge (100 crores) and therefore it could seriously hurt a company already ravaged by accusations. The second aspect is that Coalgate is not a local or state issue. It’s a national issue. What I mean is that if there is a similar issue restricted only to Hoshiarpur or Coimbatore for instance, some local/state level newspaper can get away with blackmail for a smaller sum like 10-25 lakhs or thereabouts. In the case of Coalgate, even if JSPL had succumbed to Zee there is no guarantee some other news channel, a future JPC or SIT can suppress any real offences. So for both reasons the option with JSPL was not to succumb to the alleged blackmailing.

Here’s news that’s different from the past though. The Broadcast Editors’ Association (BEA) has quickly conducted an inquiry by 3-man bench. Livemint reports: “According to BEA’s press release, a committee comprising senior broadcast journalists N. K. Singh, Dibang and Rahul Kanwal arrived at the unanimous conclusion “that Mr. Sudhir Chaudhary is found to have acted in a manner that is unbecoming of an editor and in a fashion that is prejudicial to the interest and objects of the BEA”. Predictably, Zee News has stood by its employees and its editor. A legal process will have greater bearing on the end outcome as against the BEA decision. Of course, the BEA decision is absolutely right.

Now, I have some problems with that committee of BEA that conducted the inquiry. But before that here are some rants by a tainted journalist. Haha! Who else could it be? Her tweets are reactions that truly reflect the “Albatross” around her neck that I referred to in the post “Bark in the USA”. Barkha tweets about the Zee incident as if she possesses the “innocence of journalists”. Little does it occur to this media celeb that the crimes alleged against her in Radiagate are far more serious. The allegations of “lobbying and brokering” in cabinet and govt formation are far more serious allegations than the issue of blackmailing a company for advertisements in lieu of suppression of news. She even rants that nobody is talking about it. I wonder what stops NDTV from talking about it? Even channels and newspapers avoided Radiagate till it was inevitable. Worse, in her case (unlike the BEA in this case) the head of Editors’ Guild, Rajdeep Sardesai, even defended her nonsense. It looks like she has also forgotten her own tragic and disgusting program on NDTV when she tried to defend herself. So Barkha would do well to hold her horses. That “Albatross” around her neck is going to stay for a long time.

Barkha quotes The Hindu on the Zee News case. That brings us to another question. Why are all major media outlets absolutely silent in the case of N. Ram of The Hindu and the land related FIR against him?  Reports indicated he has even sought anticipatory bail. Would NDTV care to report? Oh hang on, does NDTV have some business tie up with The Hindu? I haven’t seen any tweets from Barkha on this. Never mind! We are selective in our outrage, you see?

Now, the BEA needs to be commended to for action against Sudhir Chaudhary. However, it would have been fair if they had “suspended” him instead of “expelling” him. The final verdict on the tapes is still to be established by the police. They could have waited a bit longer before expelling him. Not very important, but the committee itself could have been differently constituted. It has at least two members who are peers of Chaudhary, Dibang and Kanwal. Instead, they could have chosen a committee of non-media members which would have made their decision even more respectable. Still, considering how deep the media mafia runs this response by the BEA is definitely a welcome change. Before cleaning up corruption in politics and govt, it’s our news media that needs a large broom. 

24 comments:

  1. Absolutely agree on all points Ravinar. Rajdeep's favourite comment "is hamaam me sab nange hain" holds more true for media than for anyone else....and barkha's rant would be irrelevent as the media WILL go to town on this in next 10-15 days.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Really Shocking .. didn't know it till I read this post .. Thanks for sharing it ..

    ReplyDelete
  3. Correct me if I'm wrong, but was the Naveen Jindal assault on journos linked to blackmail by Zee reporters?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Barkha was also asking Abhinandan sekri why newslaundry is not reporting about it .She has a grudge against everybody .I have seen newslaundry interview of Barkha with Madhu Trehan where she was seen constantly fiddling with her cellphone and does not have manners how to behave giving an interview

    ReplyDelete
  5. Copy of the FIR. The charges are serious. http://infogrid.tumblr.com/post/33357374899/fir-against-zee-news-editors

    ReplyDelete
  6. Barkha believes intensity of her crime will decrease if more numbers are added. She must realize her crime is her's for life & it will stay with her.

    Others shall pay for their crimes regardless of her rantings.

    This industry will come apart need few more such incidents.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Kyaa Sting kaa zamaana hai !!HT does a sting on Khurshid who threatens reverse sting,now this reporter is reverse stinged,everyone seems to be walking around with stingy material.In all this the core issue is lost,Didnt we hear sometime back a so called newschannel claiming that they were not newchannel but more of revenue generating advertisement channel?Where is BEA then?http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n9dKQ4IB2hY&feature=relatedBrokering News-IMDB What is being done about this too?

    ReplyDelete
  8. Please Can anyone let me know which shows/TV anchors are neutral

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Every one will have bias and preconceived notions. Only degree varies. But in the context of the media, one can tend to believe those who are honest about their bias. That is some objectivity.

      Delete
    2. neutral to koi nahi..but if u want 2 catch up on the days events( real NEWS)..watch DD news bulletin..short and sweet with no biased opinions and debates..rest depend on SM

      Delete
  9. Media receiving the fruits of sting op. These sting ops investigation is becoming a nightmare for everyone. The early the media should learn this horror (sting op) as hazard and discard it, the better it would be for everyone. I am totally against of this sting drama. Well, at least a good step taken by BEA. BD....facepalm.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I would doubt honesty of Naveen. Is he not involved in Coalgate? He or his brother, whoever runs Vijayanagar Steel in Bellary-Hospet, has been charged with bribing Yeddi. Sudhir may be guilty, but Naveen will be guilty of much deeper and more serious corporate crimes. Let us wait for the trial and judgement. But, is the justice in India fair? I doubt. It is Jungle Raj, bigger and powerful animals will devour small and helpless. Judges are like jackals, sharing the leftovers. Whole India is Fu$$$d up. Let us enjoy the whoring on display, be a Sakhshi.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Barka Dutt is behaving as if she is a queen of innocence and ethics.Well she has to live with stigma of corruption and a power broker(Read Dalli).Radia Gate is much much bigger media scam than Zee-Jindal scam.NDTV should have kicked her out long before,just like BEA kicked Chaudhary.Barkha is a shameless woman.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Seems BD's channel suffers serious competition from Zee. Hence the righteous tweets. But the channels all remain silent on the issue. Reminds of the old saying: honour among thieves.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Ravi, I expected your blog on Arnab's outrage against UK's softened stand on Modi for mutual benefits.

    ReplyDelete

  14. Dear Ravinar,

    I have a suggestion to make. If we can compile all the Media Corruption for each year & publish their Frauds on yearly basis or atleast discuss openly about who was the biggest scamster, it will be very interesting. A kind of similar to India's worst scamster journalists/Mediahouse poll would be a step in right direction.

    ReplyDelete
  15. What about this..?

    http://bharatpress.com/naveen-jindal-hired-contract-killers-to-murder-me-ramesh-agrawal-rti-activist/

    ReplyDelete
  16. http://twocircles.net/2012oct20/two_jspl_officials_surrender_court.html

    ReplyDelete
  17. Ravinar,

    I have a suggestion, why don't you publish a book of this blog? This will be also a very valuable resource for Media Courses across the country.
    Nitin

    ReplyDelete
  18. पत्रकारिता भी प्रगति पर है

    ReplyDelete
  19. Please be part of our campaign. https://www.facebook.com/pages/People-for-Responsible-Media/151318664886676

    ReplyDelete
  20. Shameless Barkha Dutt and Sudhir Choudhry should be tried in a court of law for fraud and taking their audiences like us for a ride. Instead we see day in and day out these so called journalist thieves pontificating over the corruption of Indian Netas. Arnab Goswami of Times Now would go hammer and tongs against, Salman, Kalmadi and Gadkari but is silent on the fraud committed by his own fraternity. Such hypocrisy, my God!

    ReplyDelete
  21. The idea you shared here is amazing, I appreciate your kind way of knowledge sharing! Thanks for it............Stainless Sinks

    ReplyDelete

Comments are welcome and are not moderated so as to allow free speech. However, comments that are off topic, abusive, defamatory or slanderous may be deleted. Comments disclosing personal information of individuals/entities will be deleted.Comments appearing here do not imply endorsement by author of this blog.