Friday, September 7, 2012

Simple Simon & The PrimeMin



The Americans play this game in a diamond shaped field. It somewhat resembles the game of Cricket, except instead of a wicket-keeper they have an umpire behind the hitter or batter. (Friend points out the umpire stands behind a crouching catcher). They also have the rule “three strikes and you’re out”. The ‘Three Strikes’ rule is also used by American states where a person convicted of three criminal offences is sentenced for life. Simon Denyer is an American journalist with the Washington Post but let’s not take those rules too seriously when it comes to lampooning our Prime Minister. First, the two strikes:


There, one by TIME as ‘The Underachiever’ and two by The Independent as ‘Poodle or Puppet’ (The Independent doesn’t seem to be sure which one). And the third strike was delivered by Simon himself in an article titled: “India’s ‘silent’ prime minister becomes a tragic figure”. For short, I’ll call it “Silent, Tragic figure” (STF).

In a discussion over Simon’s article in the Washington Post calling Manmohan Singh a STF on CNN-IBN on September 5 Manish Tiwari had some interesting statistics to offer. ManishT, the Congress spokesperson, mentioned that “In the last one year, the PM has held 7 press conferences and has given 82 speeches and therefore to say that he is a silent PM is completely erroneous and out of line”. That clarified the ‘S’ part but not the ‘TF’ part. Seven pressers and 82 speeches? Wow! I guess I was measuring climate change in Greenland when all that happened. And yes, Rajdeep Sardesai the “newsman” didn’t ask ManishT “when and where”? As a ‘silent’ observer I can safely risk stating that all those 82 speeches were ‘ceremonial’ speeches and do not amount to ‘talking to the people’ which is what most articles about the STF are all about. Speeches on I-Day, at the UN, at meetings of govt department heads or CMs, speeches at party meets and most recently at the redundant NAM meet in Teheran. ManishT probably also includes maybe a rare speech in parliament. Seven press conferences? Must be the ones mid-air on board Air India One.

Oh yes, I do recall the PM talking to the media and people on the ground too. I remember all those times when he said “I condemn this terrorist attack”, “This is a dastardly attack by cowards”, “Terrorists had the advantage of surprise”, “The guilty will be brought to justice” and many similar ones. The Simons of this world don’t seem to realise that terrorists have the knack of making MMS talk unlike foreign journalists.

Let’s go back in time a bit. On June 28, 2011 this is what the TOI reported: “Manmohan Singh has so far held only three nationally televised press conferences in the last seven years has been prime minister but has not been known to give interviews to the Indian media. He last spoke to editors of some TV channels four months ago”. Remember that one? That’s the one with TV editors where Harish Khare, then MMS’ media adviser, told Arnab GoswamiIt’s not an inquisition”. So June end 2011 MMS decided on an “image makeover plan” and swore “to interact with editors every week” and end this ‘silent’ tag. So he had a meeting with a select group of five chosen editors on June 29, 2011.

Why in an age of excess of communication tools would the PM of the largest democracy on earth call five editors and have a secret press conference with them? And then it was left to cronies like Kumar Ketkar of Divya Marathi and Alok Mehta of Nai Duniya to relay the discussions with MMS and interpret what STF said. For a day both Kumar and Mehta were acting PMs themselves. I had then called it “PM’s friendly fire”. What was promised as a regular weekly meet with the press started and ended with the one single farcical meet on June 29, 2011.

Before you could say “Simple Simon met a Prime-min” the PMO was demanding apologies. Some tweeted he had apologised, then clarified he had not. After thinking about it the whole night Pankaj Pachauri, the current media adviser to PM, sent a written response to Simon. Of all the laments, the classic Pachauri lament was “You told me sorry twice” on the phone. For what? Because the PMO had told Simon no interviews till end of monsoon session of parliament and he carried the article without PM’s version. That interview schedule could be anytime between now and May 2014. You take your pick. Pachauri’s note is like the one of an angry mother to a teacher about bad scores of her kid in the exams.

Of course, our courageous Indian media stood right behind Simon in condemning the demand of apology by the Congress, the govt and the PMO. Even Shoma Chaudhaury ridiculed the apology demand. Every media celeb worth anything condemned the apology demand. Yeah, it was ONE voice! Topping all the condemnations was Barkha Dutt. She was truly surprised that the govt went into a tizzy over Simon’s piece. She even tweeted on September 5: “Odd thing is the Indian media is often just as scathing in its critique of UPA but that doesn’t send the government into a tizzy”.

I really can’t remember when the Indian media was ever nice or fair to the UPA or MMS. They have been so consistently scathing in their criticism that it’s right to believe that the govt is now tired and beyond complaining even. You see, Simple Simon didn’t learn from the Indian media. The most scathing attack doesn’t come through words. It comes through hugs and high-fives. That’s how they rattle the living daylights out of the Congress and UPA. I’m positive if Simon had gotten an interview with MMS he could have hugged him, shook his hands, patted him gently on the back and politely told him with a smile: “Sir, you’re a STF”. That wouldn’t be termed “unethical” as Pachauri and PMO have complained. No wonder Barkha’s “scathing” criticism has never been termed unethical.

Nobody! Nobody in the world expects the most perfect prime minister. Somewhere in the heart of MMS it must have started to bother him over the years that he remains an “unelected” PM. A man who couldn’t win the only election he ever contested cannot have the confidence to act or to talk like one who has. MMS will likely go down as the head of the most corrupt govt India has ever seen. Even worse, he has shown himself to be a man minus scruples in allowing so many scams to happen under his very nose. What Simon Says wasn't really far from truth, but that doesn't matter. What another Indian politician said does matter a lot. Yashwant Sinha summed it up neatly when he said MMS is “An over-rated economist and an under-rated politician”. A guilty conscience often throttles speech. A Man Minus Scruples (MMS?) is likely to hear the words “STF” a lot more often. Given the heat over his article, Simple Simon may never get to meet the prime-min. 

22 comments :

  1. Hilarious and thought provoking as usual.

    Andar ki baat hai.. when MMS became PM he was told by big boss to Shut the F*** that's why he has become STF.

    Cheers

    Ramesh N

    ReplyDelete
  2. Did you read the comments section of the WaPo article? It was spammed real bad by some poster (a whole team of posters actually) called wetheindians1@hotmail.com. Most were pure bilge but some of them were hilarious and invited scathing replies from intelligent beings, some of whom seemed to be techies having fun. Sadly, some of the juicier comments by the said wetheindians1@hotmail.com have been moderated out. In those comments the congress is exposed in all its fascist, anti-freedom, anti-west, anti-Jew, pro-ayatollahs nakedness.

    The whole spamming exercise seems to be so that in a few months' time they can trot out figures - see? 900 comments are against MMS and 1500 are for MMS (not sure about the exact figures; I don't want to waste a Friday sitting down and counting such stuff).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. How can we be sure they are even from India? Remember the scam that some spy agencies are promoting online hate by fake profiles?

      Delete
    2. WaPo has now cleaned out the comments by the congress spammers, as also the replies to them, some of which were sharp and witty. The comments had gone up to more than 2000 but after the clean up they went down to about 1200+. However, they are still increasing steadily (now a bit more than 1500).

      Delete
    3. You mean congress IT Goon, Sanjay Jha is working very hard? LOL.

      Delete
  3. Hilarious and comparison! Simon lost an opportunity for ever. Not that anyone got it live (if you discount the AF-1 and a few rare interactions with select Journos) Sad state of affairs. This piece apparently looks valuable only for its humour, but hopefully everyone see it for the incisive observation and facts that it brings out.
    Superb!!!

    ReplyDelete
  4. MMS is like a court clerk elevated to be a judge ! he will forever be a clerk and act like a clerk in a judge's garb !

    ReplyDelete
  5. 82 speeches probably includes his interaction within his family !!!!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Looks like this include his sleep talks....:-)

    ReplyDelete
  7. i loathe seeing MMS How can a man can sleep at night (who is so praised for integrity and honesty ) with these huge burdens of corruption under his nose. The meaning of honesty and integrity have got new meanings and definitions by MSM and cronies in print and electronic media .They believe in old adage that a lie becomes truth when spoken repeatedly .But thanks to Social Media- the lies have been exposed . How can a man be of integrity and honesty when he is enjoying PM ship and all the advantages that come with this chair and letting others loot country in bargain . Any Tom,Dick and Harry would love to be so honest if he is offered PM chair .

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well put, the man has no conscious.

      And to think this old senile babu is the leader of a 1 billion strong democracy.

      Delete
    2. I fully agree! I too have same felling. Even dumbest of dumb, worst of shameless cannot bear this kind of public insult. What is his motive to continue like this is a quiet an enigma. There are no hints of him making any money or wealth. Nor he gets any credit or support from his own party or alliance. Is it possible that he was drugged and physically made a puppet like we see in many movies?

      Delete
  8. Truly Hilarious! Its always fun watching the rare speeches given by our beloved MMS. It feels the robot has been tuned on to read the phrased speeches

    Sanjay

    ReplyDelete
  9. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  10. 7 pressers and 82 speeches!! - that's the torture we indians have suffered .

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hi,

    Hard hitting as usual. There seems to be some issues with your site feeds. I am not getting notifications when new articles are published.

    Abhilash

    ReplyDelete
  12. MMS aka STF, the man who led India down into the gutters.

    People wake up.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Dear Sir,
    As usual excellent write up with facts.
    Our man is a perfect example that just being a Economist alone is a disaster in Politics.
    Please dont talk bad about our so called Dummy PM Mr MumMainoSingh. If only if he had got hold of that MAGIC WAND which he has been searching for many years he would not have talked like - Prices will come down in three months every three months or i strongly condemn the Bomb Blasts.
    So blame only the Magic Wand

    ReplyDelete
  14. Excellent Ravi, thanks for your analysis of PM.
    The price Indians are paying for a back room boy pretending to be PM, when he knows very well that he is only Psuedo PM. Can you Please publish the photograph of 15/8 when all the Congis are lined up, at Red Fort, to greet Mafia lady. Just see the expression on faces of MMS. To me that picture tells how pathetic and tragic it is for Indians to have this puppet as PM.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Ravi, I am looking forward to your comment on attack on police led by Mr. Tytler on Odisha police. I fell the discussion on NDTV exposed double standards of one Shoma from Tehelka. And even Kiran bedi to some extent.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I think MMS has some kind disease of loss memory because of his age or he is not in his sense because of his old age. Even Corrupt person could have offer his resignation in this situation of scams after scams but MMS is behaving as if nothing has happened and He think people still believe in his honesty & Integrity. MMS must be having some sort of old age diseases. his body must have lost the contact with brain too. :P
    I am amazed of congress confident of winning general election in 2014.

    ReplyDelete
  17. MMS got far too much kudos for an economic policy which was written for him by India's debtors. He has shown, he's no different from a Suresh Kalmadi or an A.Raja, when it comes to having a conscience. To take up a role whcih requires occupation of the highest office in India, without the authoriy or autonomy it requires is a sign of serious low self-esteem. Country first is a mantra that makes no sense to this man, who I sincrely doubt is medically or mentally capable of being the PM of 1.3b people.

    ReplyDelete

Comments are welcome and are not moderated so as to allow free speech. However, comments that are off topic, abusive, defamatory or slanderous may be deleted. Comments disclosing personal information of individuals/entities will be deleted.Comments appearing here do not imply endorsement by author of this blog.