Monday, September 24, 2012

In Denial Part-2: Covering-up Muslim Violence...



You would have heard the story of why a huge elephant refuses to break its relatively tiny chains and seek freedom. The reason is the elephant has been chained since it was a baby when it was difficult to break it. The baby elephant tried hard but couldn’t break away. By the time it grew to its mammoth size it was mentally a prisoner to that chain. It was convinced it’s futile and believed it’s not possible. Its mind had been trained to the falsehood that when it’s chained, it can't break free. Our MSM and most historians are no different. They are chained to falsehoods by the institutions that created them and cannot break free. Our school history books chain children to falsehoods too (Aryan invasion, anyone?). Most remain like the elephant but some are now managing to break free. This is the reason the new alternative media bears an important responsibility in spreading facts and truth. Some are already doing a great job of it and thousands more should join in.

Negationism is defined as denial or distortion of historical facts, especially those relating to crimes against humanity. Dr. Koenrad Elst, a Belgian, is a Hinduism scholar who has written much about this negationism and concealing of Islamic record in India. In the first part of this article I talked about history books in school. Here’s what Koenrad Elst has to say (Wiki): Historians of the Aligarh school (e.g. Irfan Habib) or Indian Marxists (e.g. Romila Thapar) have resorted to history-rewriting: "Therefore, in 1982 the National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT) issued a directive for the rewriting of schoolbooks. Among other things, it stipulated that:"Characterization of the medieval period as a time of conflict between Hindus and Muslims is forbidden." Under Marxist pressure, negationism has become India's official policy”. It actually recommends dumbing down of students. Effectively, it meant the horrors of Indian Islamic history must be hidden from our students. Students who cared were able to get to the real history but our MSM still follows that diktat. So is it a surprise that Muslim violence is covered up and mostly turned into ‘victimhood’ or an Anti-Hindu rant?

Most of us who believe in freedom of speech admire the First Amendment of US Constitution and are inspired by it. The inspiration for ‘free-speech’ for our MSM seems to be the ‘Sharia’. Hey, what the hell, let’s celebrate! It’s the Ganesh festival. You see, Gujarat has been free of communal riots for a decade now and that’s a great sign. But was it free of certain communal incidents? And it’s not just Gujarat alone. Ever wonder what is so wrong about the Ganesh “Visarjan” or the immersion procession that can be annoying to any religious community? At the most someone might complain of loud noise for a while. But in Godhra, the very epicentre of 2002, Muslims stoned a Ganesh procession in 2010. Saw a report anywhere in the MSM? No? Okay, here’s another from Miraj and Sangli in Maharashtra in 2009. No? Okay, here’s a recent one from 2012 this month from AP: Communal clashes over Ganesh idols. No? Okay, here’s another one from this month from Coimbatore Deccan Chronicle. Some have been arrested too. Are you sure you didn’t hear TV channels screaming about it? No? Then recently, online magazine The Onion , in sarcastic response to the violence over the recent anti-Islam movie, carried a very vulgar cartoon of Ganesh, Buddha, Jesus and Moses with the title “No one got murdered for this”. I’m not even going to reproduce it for obvious reasons. The Onion used it to prove a point to Muslims and not the unintended offence to other religions.

Back in January 2011 the Delhi HC ordered the demolition of an illegal mosque in the posh Jangpura locality in South Delhi. Law abiding Muslims protested, agitated and rioted and created havoc in the area. Politicians from the ‘secular’ parties rushed to pacify and promise the Muslims everything will be done to protect that illegal plot. You remember those TV images of this incident, right? Oh come on, rack your brains and recall those images! No? Oh wait! I recollect now. Just as NCERT sanitises school books, the ‘Union of Snakes’ sanitises TV where it concerns Muslim violence. Yeah, the NBA is the comic, laughable self-regulatory “union” of our TV media propagandists. That union decided: Other violence good for you, Muslim violence bad for you! Need confirmation? There’s the tweet from Barkha Dutt.

Alright, so if you’ve not heard of all of those on TV or major newspapers I’m sure you have at least had the pleasure of meeting Deganga. No, Again? Well, that’s because Deganga is not a media celeb but a small town somewhere in Bengal. If you read the CNN-IBN website report (see image) you wouldn’t know what the story really was. And, interestingly, at the bottom, there’s a disclaimer: “This is an automated feed. The contents have not been selected or edited by IBNLive”. Voila! So a robot does that and CNN-IBN doesn’t even have the time to verify the story or report it properly. Do they? That’s a smart way of covering up Muslim violence. Need more facts? Read this blog post. Don’t go by just that one blog. Please do cross-check this post with other searches on the net to assure yourself that you have the full corroborated story. The list could go on and on but let's stop with this much.

In the first part I quoted a rationalist, satirist Bill Maher. In this part, let’s read  Richard Dawkins, a rationalist, on the recent episode of the offensive movie which has spawned so much violence and deaths (this was in response to a letter by one Terence English):

Terence English makes the all too common liberal error of patronising Muslims by assuming that their bigoted intransigence is a fixed fact of life which cannot be criticised, but must be accommodated like the laws of physics. It is a dubious application, not to say misapplication, of the classic limitation on free speech where “It’s like shouting ‘Fire’ in a crowded theatre.” Well yes, I see the point but no, there is an important difference. Fire is a chemical reaction that presents huge danger to everybody in a crowded theatre. That danger follows inevitably from the laws of physics. The danger from Muslim over-reaction to trivial slights to their prophet is entirely man-made and inexcusable.  As Nick Cohen points out, in You Can’t Read this Book, the real offence is to assume that Muslims are incapable of civilised behaviour. This patronises and insults Muslims in ways that – if the liberal apologists would only think it through – goes right against their deepest liberal convictions: “Poor dears, they don’t have civilised ways like us, it’s part of their culture.” That’s the ignominiously coded meaning of “respect” in this case”.

A Muslim MP makes a statement threatening a “third wave of radicalisation” in parliament. Instead of condemning his act our TV channels hold stupid debates about it. There cannot be a debate about mindless violence and mindless threats. They deserve nothing but severe condemnation. But our little “Miss Indias” will not only suppress news reports but will identify “Victimhood” as the cause of all this Muslim violence. Victimhood justifies violence? The only real “root cause” of all the chronic violence is ignorance, illiteracy, lack of education, intolerance and most of all, lack of sane leadership. On CNN a Rabbi made a valid point today. In most Islamic countries people can be jailed or even beheaded for offending their political leaders or Kings. And so it’s imaginable why they cannot tolerate criticism or satire about their religion. Does that ring a bell? We are close to that! Our cowardly media can abuse Hindus for anything but will not dare ask a single question about Sonia Gandhi’s illness, whereabouts or how, when and where she travels abroad. That’s our courageous, fair and balanced media for you.

The root of any good or bad ideological practice is usually found in the precedents set by the founding fathers of a nation. India doesn’t really have founding fathers except her Hindu culture. But post-independence some like to give that honour to some people. Jawaharlal Nehru is often referred to as the ‘Architect of modern India’. In his book on Negationism, Koenrad Elst recalls Nehru’s admiration for Mahmud Ghaznavi

The best-known propounder of negationism was certainly Jawarharlal Nehru… his writings contain some crude cases of glorification of Muslim tyrants and concealment or denial of their crimes. Witness his assessment of Mahmud Ghaznavi, who, according to his chronicler Utbi, sang the praise of the temple complex at Mathura and then immediately proceeded to destroy it. Nehru writes: "Building interested Mahmud, and he was much impressed by the city of Mathura near Delhi". About this he wrote: "There are here a thousand edifices as firm as the faith of the faithful; nor is it likely that this city has attained its present condition but at the expense of many millions of dinars, nor could such another be constructed under a period of 200 years." And that is all: Nehru described the destroyer of Mathura as an admirer of Mathura, apparently without noticing the gory sarcasm in Ghaznavi's eulogy. Moreover, Nehru denied that Mahmud had committed his acts of destruction out of any religious motive: "Mahmud was not a religious man. He was a Mohammedan, but that was just by the way. He was in the first place a soldier, and a brilliant soldier."  I recommend that you read the whole book by Elst which is available free online.

The fountainhead of the rivers that run through most of our institutions, universities, education boards and the media lies in the nearly two decades of Nehruvian era. Communist and socialist ideologies have made sure Hindus are blamed for everything and the worst of Muslim violence is covered up. So what about the Muslims? As long as they keep providing evidence that they can be provoked easily into anger and violence there will be jokers who will keep cracking silly jokes to annoy them. Immediately after the latest movie, a French magazine, Charlie Hebdo, carried another round of cartoons about the Prophet. There were protests in France but fortunately no violence or deaths. The day they stop reacting to these cartoons they will find the cartoons disappearing. Aseem Trivedi came to prominence because some idiots got provoked, else nobody would have even heard of him or seen his cartoons. The outcome is there for all to see.

Finally, what about the MSM? In 1991 the adult elephant was compelled to break free of the Nehruvian chains and bring in some reforms as far as economic policies are concerned. Though many faulty socialist policies continue, much of Nehru’s economic, political and international ideologies have been dismantled. One good thing: Nehru was never accused of financial corruption which his party has now taken to exceptionally intolerable levels. Our media is partly a player in that corruption. The MSM is an adult elephant but still a mental prisoner of the chains of the negationism that Nehruvian era brought along. Many of the media people come from the hotbeds of Nehruvian negationism, the universities and institutions that produce them. Does that explain why they cover up Muslim violence or intolerance more often than not? In the 21st century, baby elephants in the alternative media have broken free of the chains. If the MSM chooses to be a mental prisoner the baby elephants are not going to merely watch.   

29 comments :

  1. Deganga incident is a eye opener...

    If riot at this scale is not covered by MSM, its obvious that there is deliberate bias in the media

    ReplyDelete
  2. What remains to say, I wonder if really the most secular religion, the most accommodating religion and the most ancient religion of the mankind is taking its last breaths. I also wonder what would happen when the ratio of population takes a swing.
    I fear, and I fear a lot.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Ravi,

    Thank you for yet another great one.

    I had also written on Deganga riot as they were happening on 09 Oct 2010 This is the heading "Mirror Mirror on the wall expose this face before all."

    Let's just continue to expose them on a daily basis.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I can almost feel myself strangulated ! It's so very true !!!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I can name seven Hindu kings. But can you please allow mw to name 7 Hijra PMs of India? Some of them may be still alive, so what legal issues may arise?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Ravinar..U r turning up the heat ..Rage against the Media- RATM
    < Of course the corrupt ones..) >

    ReplyDelete
  7. I can give you the recent black-out by media of the violent protests and demonstrations by muslims in one of the main commercial center in chennai the whole of last week. The violent demos saw more than 20000 muslims overwhelming the minuscule police force and at least a dozen police constables including women constables were attacked and are still in hospital. It threw traffic out of gear in all the four days for at least 4 - 6 hours. Did you hear even a whiff of it in MSM? Of course Chennai is more remote than the obscure bars in Mangalore, so naturally it was the "tyranny of distance" which deterred the MSM in covering these demos.

    ReplyDelete
  8. the more ur blogs are read , the more the spirit is awakened

    ReplyDelete
  9. Will you come out with Part III? This is too addictive! No denying the fact that I agree with each and every words of yours.

    ReplyDelete
  10. A request to ravi and all learned readers of this blog: Please suggest some books/websites on the true versions of Indian history. We all grew up reading the distorted versions. It would be interesting to know the real thing.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am sorry about the typo, "Ravi"!

      Delete
    2. "The History of India, as Told by Its Own Historians. The Muhammadan Period" by H. M. Elliot ,this books contain translation of muslims record,and not conclusion as done by Marxist historians but this book is quit lengthy and available in 8 volumes,you can also read books written by sir jadunath sarkar an eminent historian.for quik reference you can log on to http://www.aurangzeb.info/ this short site has pages from history and really very good for proper understanding.

      Delete
    3. you can read books by Ramesh Chandra Majumdar on Indian anciant and modern history.

      Delete
    4. You can also read following books:
      The Muslim Conquest OF INDIA by Will Durant
      http://www.scribd.com/doc/28014130/Moslem-Conquest-of-India-by-Will-Durant

      Negationism in India by Koenraad Elst
      http://www.voiceofdharma.org/books/negaind/

      Delete
    5. Soumen, please go to the website Bharat Rakshak and search a thread for Out of India theory.

      Also read writings of Tilak

      Delete
  11. Interesting read, keep writing !!!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Dear Sir: You are doing to the media what Arun Shourie did to the establishment in the 1980s. Your statements are backed by facts. Of course, Shourie did play cat and mouse with his targets, by anticipating their lies and withholding some crucial facts, till they duly lied, and then revealing the lies in all their glory. Obviously you can't do that with MSM because they don't normally reply to you. I open Media Crooks now every morning, and I expect many in the MSM ought to be going it too. Their stony silence is music to the ears, however.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Dear Sir

    One thing I must say you are just Brilliant..Unfortunately we don't have such brilliant writers in MSM...Yes if this Muslims Menace is NOT controlled..then I sure it will be a big hit to India's Secularism...Why India is Secular because secularism is in DNA of HIndus..however these communists media people always make fund of our tollerance...MSM never cover muslim news of Violence some days back one muslim scholar abuse our devi devtas..Owaisi openly abused Shri Ram...I am in fear if there is a swing of population then worst we will see..The MSM talks about Gujrat Riots but never talk about Godhara .when muslim group burnt 57 hindus alive..May be lives of Hindus are cheap..

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. correcting sentence "these communists media people always make fun of our tollerance".

      Delete
    2. (Please forgive)Correcting sentence " these communist media people always make fun of our 'tolerance'(tollerance)."

      Delete
    3. relax...chill..we got ur point ;)

      Delete
  14. When you put the feeling in our heart as words, what else I could say than - I SALUTE YOU Ravi!

    You are really gifted with the art of putting feelings in many of our hearts as words. More power to you!! Even more power to your words in this blog!!!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Muslim intolerance and their rigid religious behaviour is highly disturbing , Hinduism has been suffering partly because of selfish people, we do not care abt fellow hindus, we only exploit them, i m talking abt the rich who can afford supporting others,on the contrary , muslims and christians support each other vehemently , i am talking abt random people who may hav looked at each othr while waiting at a traffic signal , they hav a sense of togetherness, a sense of brotherhood , in hindus , personal ego far outweighs brotherly feelings( but we show btotherly feelings 2wards other religions :-)) , and hence the deep divide , we care little abt our fello beings irrespectiv of religion, non-hindus on the othr hand support vehemently people of their own religion , added to our personal ego ,is a draconic caste system and sucker govt which exploits evry bit of it to the core , we are victims of our own ego and differences , both these factors , our differences and the unity among othr religions is killing india's core, the media again is no exception , its made f the same people as the country , i think we should rethink our own attitudes and learn frm non-hindus , they are wrong in being violent,and intolerant , but they stand united when any1 frm their religion is in pain. But , there definitely is hope , we may be suffering , but Lord Krishna will come one day , to cleanse the earth , all the work done by any human being(non-hindus or hindus) to suppress,hurt and eliminate krishna believers will we wiped out,all those who are causing pain to the Lord's devotees , will be made to pay for their dues , This has been the history of earth for ages and ages ,

    ReplyDelete
  16. Dear Ravinar,

    I came across this amazing Article from "The Daily Beast".
    I sincerely hope everyone reads this story of how a devout Muslim women denounced her religion to become secular. Single handedly withstood the Muslim rage & showed courage to speak her free mind. Check the LINK below:

    http://www.thedailybeast.com/newsweek/2012/09/16/ayaan-hirsi-ali-on-the-islamists-final-stand.html

    ReplyDelete
  17. Great that you wrote about Elst. That introduces his name to the people who had not read his books. This would encourage them to read more about the facts not the sugaries masquerading as historical facts.

    One more thing : while u recommend Elst's book of Negationism, there is one more essential book of Arun Shourie to be read to know the crimes of Marxist historians : "Eminent Historians" !!

    ReplyDelete
  18. Dear Ravi, your all posts are awesome.

    I have one question for you, have anyone from media or politics tried to threaten you. Since you write naked truth backed by facts , which might be a pain for lot of ppl.


    ReplyDelete
  19. Saudi Arabia Govt demolished the Mosque where Mohammed [PBUH] used to pray and also demolished the house where he used to stay. Saudi Arabia govt routinely demolishes Mosques for widening of roads, constructing palaces and malls. But in India, the Metro Rail routes are diverted to save Mosques and even the Muslim burial lands. The secular state of India gives unwanted importance to Mosques and thereby insulting the Islam.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Ravi,

    One more incident, on the day of your post.

    Attack during Ganesh immersion. Attack was so intense that the head constable got killed.

    http://www.deccanherald.com/content/280884/head-constable-killed-clash-silence.html

    This news is definitely worth to be covered at national level (surely much more worthwhile than slapping incident of M'lore).

    Have not watched news lately, so don't know whether it got covered.

    ReplyDelete

Comments are welcome and are not moderated so as to allow free speech. However, comments that are off topic, abusive, defamatory or slanderous may be deleted. Comments disclosing personal information of individuals/entities will be deleted.Comments appearing here do not imply endorsement by author of this blog.