Thursday, December 16, 2010

Do You Really Trust CNBC-TV18 ?

“CNBC-TV18 today is clearly the last word in business news. CNBC-TV18 is a joint venture between Network18 and CNBC, the global leader in business television”. That is what their website tells us. With the Radia tapes exposing many journalists and news channels and newspapers,  the financial networks haven’t received much attention. They, of course, offer wisdom on how your money works best or how the economy is doing or what shares will do well. But do they always tell you the facts? Can you trust them? Let’s take the case of CNBC-TV18. The TV18 group is headed by none other than Raghav Bahl, the author of a recent book called ‘Superpower’. Yes, he should know everything about power. 

                     Udayan Mukherjee - Pays 6 Crores as Income Tax?

Girish Nikam, a journalist, has been following the telecom scandal for quite a long time. Following the second round of the Radia tapes exposure in Outlook magazine, here are some extracts from his site: (in colour and edited for space by me)

What does Raghav Behl, the MD of TV 18(CNBC TV 18 and CNN-IBN), have to say about Manoj Modi (right hand man of Mukesh Ambani) claiming (on June 10,2009) in his conversation with Niira Radia that he told(threatened) him(Raghav) “your organisation is corrupt…. Even factual stories you don’t print about ADAG and you will work for us. I want to know who is the source, Mukesh(Ambani) ko personally attack karega toh main manoj modi hoon, chodega nahin kisiko.——-Raghav said in order to put pressure on me(Raghav himself)— send me(raghav) a legal notice”...... Did Raghav Behl ask Modi to send him a legal notice? If not true, did Raghav Behl get a letter from Modi, making such threats, as Modi claims in this tape and repeatedly asks Niira Radia not to disclose about it to anyone?

In one of the conversations(on June 13,2009) .......Niira Radia remarks that “Sebi investigations is on against Siddharth(Zarabi, Economic Policy Editor, CNBC TV 18), Udayan(mukherjee, anchor and MD CNBC TV 18)....they are getting their wives involved in the (stock) market), and the SEBI investigation is on”. She also goes on to say that Udayan Mukherjee “files the highest tax returns among journalists…… he pays Rs.6 crore as income tax, and he doesn’t even earn that much”. Now what has Raghav Behl and his colleagues named here done about these obviously serious charges? Is what she is saying true? If not what action are they contemplating or have taken?
Make no mistake whatsoever. CNBC-TV18 and other financial channels as also most of our news channels and journals can only be expected to be faithful to their paymasters. The viewers and readers are their last priorities. And if you believe all the stories that appear on financial channels, do so at your own risk. Most financial journalists eat from the palms of corporate bosses and advertisers. Not convinced yet? Let’s go to the global CNBC itself.

In my post ‘Servantile Journalism’ in March 2010 this is what I wrote:

"... In March 2009 in his now famous smack-down of CNBC (the American financial channel) Jon Stewart of The Daily Show showed how the journalists at CNBC asked all stupid and servantile questions to CEOs of companies like Bear Sterns, AIG, GM, Merryl Lynch, one even went far enough to ask Allen Stanford “how does it feel to be a billionaire?” ....In weeks after the interviews each company collapsed and Stanford was actually running a Ponzi-scheme. Yes, the very same Allen Stanford who sponsored a cricket event in the WI. The point here is, the journalists sucked up to the CEOs of these companies and never asked real hard questions that would indicate the health of their companies. The end result was the economic collapse in the US."    View the full Jon Stewart CNBC smackdown video HERE.

That US economic collapse also affected India. There were suicides by many financially broken people. When it comes to your money beware of servantile journalists and channels. When it comes to financial channels, be cynical. Be very cynical. Can you really trust them?


  1. Ask any person who actively trades on the Indian indexes (BSE or NSE), follow the so called TV experts and you are doomed. CNBC is mockingly referred to as Cartoon Network Business Channel amongst trader communities. New retail investors are regularly trapped by following news, 'tips or calls' about stocks. These so called expert bozos like Udayan don't buy stocks they recommend but sell since there will more buyers than sellers, following their advice, taking the stock price higher. I repeat, any person who follows these business channel jokers will see his capital vanish in no time, that is a promise. Thanks to the blogger for info on SEBI investigation being done on Siddharthm Udayan etc..although nothing will come out it and everything will be hushed up or more likely, these frauds will be given a clean chit.

  2. The Micro-finance Bill, which was ready, is now to be re-formulated again, taking into account the recent developments in Andhra Pradesh. Within the Congress,

  3. The first rule that we learn in finance during our MBA classes, you cannot earn returns more than what market earns, simple rule
    It has been conclusively proven in many experiments that the so called "Stock market geniuses" are no better than randomly thrown darts at a stock list. No one has managed to beat the market consistently. Believe me I can come up with any value for the stock of any company, all I need to do is change few (with 0.1 range) changes in my forecasting calculation. So all that people say on TV is absolute certified Bullshit. In fact its proven that even Mutual funds cannot beat the markets, So if you want to earn from stock markets, just do one thing, invest in passive indexed funds, thats it
    for the experiment look at this site

  4. can anyone tell me the level of casting couch involved in tv news channels...becuase only male are fired frm job as recent is happen in cnbc tv 18.......

  5. That beside other accolades across national and international platforms. These include the coveted Indian Telly Awards, Indian Television Academy Awards, and News Television Awards.
    steven rattner


Comments are welcome and are now being moderated due to excessive spam on older posts. Genuine comments by readers will not be blocked. However, comments that are off topic, abusive, defamatory or slanderous may be deleted. Comments disclosing personal information of individuals/entities will be deleted.Comments appearing here do not imply endorsement by author of this blog.